When Rose Tylers (Billie Piper) hand slipped from that bar we all knew it was the end of the character.

Yes, deep down we knew.

We also had a pretty good idea that she would be back. What we didnt count on was her leaving again so soon.

Two heartbreaks for the same character may have interested some people. But for me it didnt do too much, as for most others.

The ending of Journeys End was good, yes. But I urge you to reconsider not shooting a spin off series to follow Rose Tylers and The New Doctors (David Tennant) life.

It would excite many of the fans who have grown on The Ten/Rose relationship, myself included.

So please, just consider it.