1. Create Petition
2. FAQ

6122 Signatures

• niki b
• natalia

  • Comments
  • bring siobhan back!
• Daniel O

  • Comments
  • I love you Siobhan
• Emily F
• Rita
• Kathryn
• Yen D
• mlesherr
• Stephanie K
• Marley M

  • Comments
  • Aaron Kelly's phone number was posted instead of Siobhan Magnus's phone number this just isn't fair. She was cheated
• Edie D

  • Comments
  • this was a horrible thing to do to Siobhan-I cannot believe the 'official' American Idol page gave out the wrong telephone numbers for Siobhan. You should offer her an on air apology and keep her safe if she was the one going to be eliminated. If I were Siobhan, I would SUE American Idol and Fox for doing this to her.
• Bridget T

  • Comments
  • I believe this could sabotage Siobhan's chance for votes. I sometimes miss the numbers bc I am a mother to a toddler and get distracted. I look on facebook to get the numbers and luckily this time I had the correct numbers. Had I have depended on the facebook page I would have completely voted for a contestant that I would have never voted for.
• Brad M

  • Comments
  • Not fair, someone cheated her
• Sean S

  • Comments
  • REDO THE VOTING!
• Liza T
• Debbie H

  • Comments
  • This mistake cheated this future star out of votes and she was eliminated by it. All other prediction sites had her at number one. If something is not done about this, I swear I will never watch AI again.
• susan
• Betty R

  • Comments
  • Sioban's got more ability than at least two of the remaining contestants (and more personalty than all of 'em), but rules are rules. HOWEVER if there was an incorrect posting of voting phone numbers...
• Mallory

  • Comments
  • What the actual f*ck? Seriously, what? I can't even get my thoughts straight. This can't be right, can it? The ultimate idol robbery isn't even enough to describe this injustice.
• Chris and Katherine M

  • Comments
  • CLEARLY grounds to bring her back as the vote was tainted. In comparison to the other performers there is no way that Siobhan was the least favored by America tonight
• Jessica F
• Kevin
• chookoolat
• Laurie
• Matthew M

  • Comments
  • She was the only one who sounded good with high notes and never was even in the bottom 3 and was praised by all judges.. Something is serioously wrong here.
• Jacob

  • Comments
  • Pull the "SHANIA TWAIN" "BACK" Into The Station!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Stop the Travesty!! American Idol JUMPS THE SHARK tonight unless they UNDO the travesty!!!!
• Omarangelys C

  • Comments
  • Honest to God, it's not fair!!! Siobhan Magnus is the talented, gorgeous, unique, quirky superstar that not only America needs, but the superstar that the WORLD needs. I've never met this girl in my life, but as soon as Ryan said she was leaving, I bawled like if I just lost a loved one. I swear, just writing this gets to me, it's crazy!!! But she has been one of the best talents on AI history. She was the only reason to watch American Idol this season. Aaron, you are SO talented, especially at your age, but heck, your no Siobhan!!! SIOBHAN, WE LOVE YOU!!! Do all of your fans around the world a favor, and keep your head held high, never give up, and keep on, cause even though I'm no psychic, I KNOW that this is not the last time we'll see SIOBHAN MAGNUS shine like you did on the Idol stage!!! YOU INSPIRE ME!!! Keep that smile girl!!!
• Ashley J
• jamie m

  • Comments
  • can u repair this,my husband is going nuts,he is cussing,and fussing,i know its only a show,but he loves siobhan,and i do like to see him happy.
• joani a

  • Comments
  • if this is true, then American Idol should at least acknowledge it so that the recording companies will be able to see it and she will be offered a contract. That seems fair.
• Marc M

  • Comments
  • Please consider this petition seriously. There is no way that Siobhan recieved the least amount of votes last night, never been in B3 and all of sudden she is and then is eliminated? Get real!!
• Jayne M

  • Comments
  • Facebook has been allowed to cause too much damage to people - girl in South Hadley who committed suicide because of harassment, etc. Now this mix up with Siobhan's number. Facebook needs to right this wrong in any way they have to and the vote should be redone. Enough corruption and incompetency in the U.S.
• Lisa E
• siobhanforever
• doug e

  • Comments
  • Something is wrong with the show. Siobhan was the most creative and exciting star of season 9.
• Britney

  • Comments
  • Mark my words, Siobhan will sell more records then any idol this season... including the winner. Siobhan is up there with (Carrie Underwood, Adam Lambert, Kelly Clarkson). The idols that are left will just be another (Ruben Studdard, Kris Allen, and Taylor Hicks) for idol... pitty vote... easily forgetten later. SERIOUSLY, what happen to taking RISKS on idol... everyone with the exception of Siobhan, is playing it safe and boring! Siobhan for Life.
• sal b

  • Comments
  • i t hink what they did was wrong. i say siobhan was screwed! not fair and it sucks that she got eliminated t onight!
• michael m

  • Comments
  • NO WAY! There is no way this happend, The only person on A.I. that was her competition is Crystal. These 2 women are far better than all of the guys! This sucks and should be fixed!
• Jackie F

  • Comments
  • Wrong number listed in past on Idol, they made it right by making it a non-elimination week. They should do so again.
• Esrom M

  • Comments
  • Siobhan will not be eliminated if they post the correct number. It is evident because Aaron is shockingly safe after weeks being in the bottom 3. It is because most of Siobhan's votes went to him
• Ryan

  • Comments
  • You think Idol learned from the Adam Lambert season... I guess the show will alway be hopeless for TRUE GREATS. Siobhan was in a league of her own... Idol said they wanted someone like Taylor Swift... look like they threw away the closest thing to that. WHAT A MISTAKE!
• Miley B

  • Comments
  • I'm soo PISSED they used the save on mike a few weeks back... Siobhan WAS Season 9, she was robbed and they know it!!! Honestly now I could careless who wins, give it to Mike for all I care, so he can take the show with him to toliet
• charlie d
• Diane L

  • Comments
  • what a shame she was the best singer on Idol ive watched Idol since the beginning with kelly clarkson and siobhan is just as good as her what a mistake that she should have to pay for some one elses screw up I LOVE YOU SIOBHAN MAGNUS YOU ARE MY AMERICAN IDOL AND A MILLION OTHER PEOPLE S IDOL
• ali e
• John
• Ginger A
• Jade

  • Comments
  • We love you SHIOBHAN
• MTD

  • Comments
  • Please bring her back
• jojo

  • Comments
  • vote for Siobhan

• 6122
  Signatures!
  
• View Signatures
• Sign Petition