Fund Top Surgery for FTMs in Scotland

  • Author:
    n/a
  • Send To:
    NHS and Scottish Parliament.
  • Sponsored By:
    FTMs and their families and friends in Scotland.
  • More Info at:
We, the undersigned, are appalled at the treatment FTM (female-to-male transgendered) men have received from the NHS in Scotland with regards to obtaining 'top surgery' (mastectomy) as part of their transition.

Top surgery is an integral part of transition, and is a deeply important step in the lives of FTM men. Without it, consequences range from severe depression to physical and mental pain, and social anxiety.

The necessity of wearing binders while waiting for top surgery to be carried out puts a great deal of stress on the body. It can lead to complications such as, but not limited to: sciatica, cervical radiculopathy, severe migraines, and torn muscles.

Many FTM patients successfully undergo the many stages of 'lower surgery' (metoidioplasty and phalloplasty), experiencing no issues with funding, however, many are refused funding for top surgery, despite prevailing medical opinion and agreed care pathways. To be refused top surgery at this stage is, we believe, cruel, irresponsible, and dangerous.

In addition, patients undergoing lower surgery whilst top surgery continues to be denied are forced to live with an anomalous physical appearance which, in itself, leads to anguish and distress, negating many of the positive benefits of this surgery.

For many FTM patients, no clear reason has ever been given as to why their funding has been denied, cut, or taken back after they were assessed by surgeons and informed that top surgery could go ahead. Some patients have even been given firm confirmation and a surgery date, only to have been told a matter of days before that the surgery would not be performed, due to funding issues.

We wish to bring to the attention of our Members of Parliament, Members of the Scottish Parliament, and NHS heads, the human cost of this funding issue. It means that our friends, husbands, partners, brothers, fathers, and sons are not being treated, and are suffering in silence. For large numbers of FTM patients, the wait for this urgent and necessary surgery has been ongoing for many years. The distress associated with such seemingly interminable delays cannot be overstated.

While we can certainly understand that a lack of competent surgeons may lead to long waiting lists, we do not accept that there can be any legitimate reason to simply refuse care. This is manifestly unjust.

We find it troubling that a surgery which is carried out as a matter of routine in other parts of the UK is being refused to Scottish patients. We are sure you will agree that every Scottish patient is equally deserving of proper care as his counterpart in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland.

We challenge those in authority to comply with the Standards of Care and professional advice. Provide top surgery to FTM patients in Scotland, and allow them to live their lives fully, happily, and with dignity.

102 Signatures

  • Nicholas Green
    • Comments
    • Seven years, and counting!
  • Elizabeth Fyvie
  • Travis Reeves
  • Isabel Green
  • Ros Stanley
  • Rebecca Jones
  • Arlen Andrew Donald
  • N KHWAJA
  • Heena Patel
  • Victoria Clarke
    • Name and Address
    • Cambridge, UK
  • Kate Worland
  • Anna Mathers
  • Arlen A S Bone
  • Eva Davidson
  • Dean Worthington
  • Matthew MacDonald
  • Liam Wright
  • Chris Jones
  • M Ward
  • Liz Church
    • Comments
    • В
    • Name and Address
    • В
  • Terry Abbott
    • Name and Address
    • Manchester
  • James Morton
    • Name and Address
    • Edinburgh
  • Cayden Andrews
    • Comments
    • В
    • Name and Address
    • В
  • Steven Leather
    • Comments
    • Expecting a man to live with breast is in humane.
  • Alec Rook
  • Kai Cain
    • Comments
    • This is an outrage!
  • damon libby
    • Name and Address
    • 5 richie place, edinburgh eh11 1dt
  • Nathan Gochin
  • Lee Gale
    • Comments
    • To deny this human right is awful. It greatly enhances quality of life and in a lot of cases means that a person can actually have life.
  • Les Campbell
    • Comments
    • FTM chest surgery is the first thing that should be funded, as for most, chest binding is extremily difficult, so without surgery I dont believe they can possibly live full time as men
  • Denise Anderson
  • Polly Conroy
    • Name and Address
    • Polly Conroy
  • Rev Dr Mercia Josephine McMahon
    • Comments
    • top surgery is vital for FTMs and should be funded as part of trans healthcare programmes
    • Name and Address
    • London
  • Lucy Phelps - Garrett
  • Abi Christopher
    • Comments
    • Trans men deserve equality in GRS
    • Name and Address
    • Abi Christopher, Milton Keynes
  • Hazel Rees
  • Eve Merrick-Williams
    • Comments
    • Trans people seem to be the only minority it is acceptable to discriminate against.
  • Nick Jarvis
  • Paul Head
  • Matthew Donnelly
    • Comments
    • I was on a waiting list for a year and a half to have top surgery but ended up having to pay to have it done privately even though I could not afford to do this because I could not suffer any longer. It is cruel to put people through these long waiting periods.
  • Eden Walker
    • Comments
    • F2M can't be expected t transition without this procedure.For many this is the biggest moment of their lives. How can you deny this treatment.
  • Lisa Burscheidt
  • David Baxter
  • Debra Bell
  • Robert Nightingale
  • Jade Ellen
  • Emma Jacobs
    • Name and Address
    • Sheffield
  • Natalie Boon
    • Comments
    • В
    • Name and Address
    • В
  • Teal Salkeld
  • I Thomson