Bring Back Pizza Hut's "Big New-Yorker"

  • Author:
    n/a
  • Send To:
    Pizza Hut
  • Sponsored By:
    The entire freaking world
  • More Info at:
Are you the Author?
In 1999, you introduced the Big New Yorker pizza. This was perhaps the single most important culinary contribution you have offered to the world, with the exception of your bread stick/dipping sauce combo.

This pizza wasn't just good, it was the best. It was big, floppy, tangy and most importantly, just $9.99.

Life was good with the Big NY, as it affectionately became known. Video games were more fun, parties had that extra element, and people seemed to get along better knowing that your tasty treat was on the way.

And then it all stopped...

You, Pizza Hut, inexplicably decided to discontinue the masterpiece. For the last 6 years I have been going over possible reasons for your actions in my head, but each is as outlandish as the last.

Did we not appreciate the pizza enough?
їWas it a because of El Niсo?
Did you ACTUALLY think that the Pizzone was a better idea??

The world's love affair with the Big New Yorker has been on hold, but it is not yet over. And for this reason, we are asking you to bring back the Big New Yorker. Not for you, not for us, but for the honor of the pizza.

Thank you, and good day.

302 Signatures

  • Chad Simpson
    • Comments
    • Fold it, eat it.
  • Jeff Brush
    • Comments
    • BNY4LFE
  • cara
    • Comments
    • В
  • Caitlin
    • Comments
    • I EAT BIG NEW YORKERS FOR BREAKFAST
  • Brent Rhoden
    • Comments
    • when i wake up i eat a slice of big new yorker before pissing and brushing my teeth.
  • Alex Jordan
  • Stacy Holton
    • Comments
    • PLEASE bring it back...it's my favorite pizza!!
  • Ryan Bean
    • Comments
    • i want a big new yorker!
  • john
  • Kirk Ebert
    • Comments
    • Best pizza ever, I crave a big floppy slice so bad right now.
  • Kerry Dodds
    • Comments
    • PLEEEEEEASE bring back my favorite pizza of all time!!!
  • javier guerra
    • Comments
    • Please bring this back
  • Matt
    • Comments
    • Please bring it back
  • Danny Breton
    • Comments
    • please,,,,,
  • mike killmon
    • Comments
    • mikekillmon@gmail.com
  • John Caulfield
    • Comments
    • I haven't been to Pizza Hut since you discontinued the Big New Yorker. Bring it back and I'm back. Simple as that.
  • Katherine Heigh
  • Kate Klement
    • Comments
    • Best pizza, ever.
  • Vanessa Martinez
  • Andrew Flores
  • Alex Balin
  • Albert Elmazovski
    • Comments
    • Pizza Hut is just not the same anymore with out the Big New Yorker!
  • Sage Russell
    • Comments
    • I was longing for this earlier tonight, I miss this pizza and the Insider!
  • Ashley Hall
  • sam shockley
  • matt owoc
    • Comments
    • Bring back the Big New Yorker pizza. tsrh
  • jon wyatt
  • Jason
    • Comments
    • Please bring back the New Yorker (Calgary, AB Canada)
  • Stacy Buckley
    • Comments
    • It was the best, I often ordered it and often wish i could order it, bring it back!
  • Caleb Carpenter
    • Comments
    • The Big New Yorker was and is the best pizza I have ever had. Please, just bring it back.
  • Brent Genito
    • Comments
    • Bring this back!
  • Nick k
    • Comments
    • Please bring back the piZza
  • John Johnson
  • Darlene Collins
    • Comments
    • This pizza was great, especially the sweet sauce!
  • chris larson
    • Comments
    • Bring it back that pizza was kick ass
  • J Taylor
    • Comments
    • This is a fantastic petition... I will order a Big NY the day they bring it back.
  • Brad Bromwell
  • Greg Layton
  • Aaron Whitehead
    • Comments
    • When I worked at Pizza Hut 10 years ago I had every pizza imaginable and this was by far the best one. Please bring it back! Thank you.
  • Rohan Jain
  • Mindy Schmidt
    • Comments
    • I would boycott all other pizza chains if you brought back the big NY
  • Christopher Chambers
    • Comments
    • The pain from my gastronomic severence from The Big New Yorker Pizza is second only to the pain inflicted by McDonalds' discontinuance of the Arch Deluxe. And then you replaced it with an inferior product--insult to injury.
  • Mark DeAnda
  • Kristi Potter
  • Aimee Menninger
    • Comments
    • Please?
  • jeff slipiec
  • jeff maes
    • Comments
    • best pizza ever
  • Mike Lopez
  • Robert Romero
    • Comments
    • just that it was the best pizza ever!!!!
  • Christine McKay