Eliminate Peace Officer Status for TBTA Officers
-
Author:
n/a -
Send To:
NYS Senate
-
Sponsored By:
-
More Info at:
To: NYS SENATE & ASSEMBLY
I am a resident of the State of New York and strongly appose Senate Bill S1021 and Assembly Bill A1386 sponsored by Senator Maltese, Senator Marchi, and Member of Assembly Abbate, respectively. This Bill will change the CPL and grant Police Officer status to Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Authority Officers, and increase the burden on the tax payers to hire more toll collectors, since they seek to become police officers.
As Peace Officers, their powers to act are curtailed regularly. The tragedy of September 11, 2001 temporarily circumvented restrictions placed on these peace officers and now they seek full police status. Unfortunately the majority of the TBTA officers wouldn't be able to pass the tests to become police officers. Furthermore, the TBTA, under the control of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) already has their own police department, which has personnel assigned to the TBTA sites on a daily basis. The creation of a specific TBTA Police would simply create a greater expense for the people who use the TBTA crossings.
Finally, I would strongly support eliminating the TBTA from having peace officer status, and simply allow them to collect tolls and leave policing to the MTA Police.
Through this petition we strongly urge the Senate and Assembly to appose this bill and see that it never becomes New York State Law.
I am a resident of the State of New York and strongly appose Senate Bill S1021 and Assembly Bill A1386 sponsored by Senator Maltese, Senator Marchi, and Member of Assembly Abbate, respectively. This Bill will change the CPL and grant Police Officer status to Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Authority Officers, and increase the burden on the tax payers to hire more toll collectors, since they seek to become police officers.
As Peace Officers, their powers to act are curtailed regularly. The tragedy of September 11, 2001 temporarily circumvented restrictions placed on these peace officers and now they seek full police status. Unfortunately the majority of the TBTA officers wouldn't be able to pass the tests to become police officers. Furthermore, the TBTA, under the control of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) already has their own police department, which has personnel assigned to the TBTA sites on a daily basis. The creation of a specific TBTA Police would simply create a greater expense for the people who use the TBTA crossings.
Finally, I would strongly support eliminating the TBTA from having peace officer status, and simply allow them to collect tolls and leave policing to the MTA Police.
Through this petition we strongly urge the Senate and Assembly to appose this bill and see that it never becomes New York State Law.
463 Signatures
-
Paul Oliveri
- Comments
- Please save our tax dollars and support this petition!!
-
Ramon Gimmler
- Comments
- If we eliminate these TBTA people standing around at the tolls, we can save future fare hikes.
-
Tom Thumb
-
Edward Camuso
- Comments
- I support this petition and the more I understand about their peace officer status find it alarming we waste money to pay these people who look like cops, but are merely guards.
-
LOUIS N GARGUILO
-
KILE J GARGUILO
-
JOHN BOTTONE
-
Mike Conti
-
Tim Corcoran
- Comments
- Live from Bagdad.... make the mopes count change.
-
Bob O'Neal
- Comments
- It's about time somebody noticed that these people should be colecting tolls and leave the police work to real trained police.
-
Harry O'Reilly
- Comments
- Make em wear tan uniforms too
-
Mark Noens
- Comments
- They need to have a nice haircut
-
Ricky Rocket
- Comments
- zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz oops I dozed off. What does Noens mean???
-
Ralph Salzano
- Comments
- SAVE OUR TAX DOLLARS AND STOP THIS BLL!!!!!
-
Ray Gimmler
- Comments
- The underlying costs of changing their status will only add more burden to the tax payers.
-
Louis "Chick" LoPresti
-
Ron Reale
-
Steve McCabe
- Comments
- STOP THE BILL ----- SAVE OUR TAXES
-
Scott McCrain
- Comments
- I support this bill, and the known fact that Murphy does Borowicz in the azz.
-
Scott McCrain
- Comments
- I meant I DON'T support the bill. I support the petition... and Borowicz gives Murphy dirty sanchez.
-
Pete Hernandez
- Comments
- Go Mets
-
Bill Waring
- Comments
- Holla out to my MTA bros.... cut me a break calling the PBA offices... I am tired of covering for these guys when they're out cutting their lawns, working other jobs or playing golf on PBA time.
-
Sally Johnson
- Comments
- No more waste, the TBTA needs to be stopped!
-
star fish
- Comments
- I hope to get another picture of you MTA police sleeping real soon,punks.. you wish you made TBTA money!
-
Kimberleigh D. Vevo
- Comments
- This is an imperative move.
-
BRIDGE AND TUNNEL OFFICERS AND SERGEANTS
- Comments
- It amazes me that people would want to eliminate people they know nothing about. Or maybe it is the fact that the MTA Police are affraid since the TBTA Officers make more arrest, write more summonses and even though they are Peace Officers act more like police then the suppossed MTA police. Why not ask an MTA police officer where they were on 9-11-01, well I do believe they raced as fast as they could to the QMT...to bad the emergency was at the BBT and the Officers, Sergeant's who work the BBT not only raced to the scene but stayed there saving lives when all hell was braking loose. They do not need to read about themselves in the papers, they know that they are TRUE HEROS.....maybe we can all read about the MTA police in the paper about running drunk and naked at GC station....GIVE THEM WHAT IS DUE THEM....TBTA FOR LIFE.
-
Edward Kalanz
-
Joan Maietta
-
Squireeeeeel
- Comments
- First of all TBTA is self funded and this has nothing to do with tax dollars. Second if TBTA wants to save money they should stop payin 70 cents from every dollar they make to pay MTA Police pay checks all those guys do is sleep on duty and run aroun naked on duty. And if they are Police why is it TBTA COPS make 100% of all arrests at TBTA Facilities and run 100 % of all check points at MTA bridges and tunnels. LIke it or not TBTA COPs ARE COPS and MTA crap should stick to lookin out for turnstyle hoppers cause when the tempeture drops to 10 degrees outside TBTA is out there 24/7 saving lives not hiding in a car. Imagine a City with TBTA not arresting thousands of drunk drivers a year, we all know MTA police never has done this for our city. Also more truth: there are no MTA police on tbta facilities everyday its a LIE. TBTA Officers Double their numbers in uniformed officers.Security guards dont make arrests or write summonses or perform every police function that we do. Your outclassed and make No $$$
-
Sgt William J Reiner TBTA
- Comments
- We are officers who believe the ultimate goal is obtaining "Full Police Status" under the CPL of NYS. This does not mean however that we believe that we are any less "police" without it. We already do the job of TBTA's police force, for it is we, not the MTA police that man the checkpoints, patrol the bridges and tunnels and arrest the DWI's and other offenders that use our roadways. We issue the numerous summonses for violations of TBTA rules and regulations, NYC traffic rules, NYS vehicle and traffic law and other offenses. We deploy the bomb search mirrors, use handheld radiation pagers to uncover weapons of mass destruction and are trained to detect counterfiet and fraudulent documents. We are the first to respond to fires, medical emergencies and criminal acts on our bridges and tunnels. We, not the MTA police! Yes, we do it all! Yes we are the TBTA's Police! Don't let anyone fool you, we are the police. You like to refer to yourselves as "the Real Police" No way there is only One Real Police - NYPD
-
YeaRight
- Comments
- Just what we need nuts like this: BTO King received a reprimand after charges were brought following his arrest for menacing a female acquaintance on three separate occasions with his gun
-
Quoted
- Comments
- would take it seriously if you plan to photograph these bridges in nyc. TBTA peace officers were never armed in the past, and in my judgement they could be dangerous with a loaded weapon in their hands. They are not nyc police officers.
-
-
BTO
- Comments
- THE MTA PD SHOULD TAKE A HISTORY ESSON, EVEN BEFORE BTO'S WERE IN THE CPL (1974) WE CARRIED FIREARMS UNDER THE PUBLIC AUTHORITIES LAW, MADE ARRESTS AND ISSUED SUMMONSES, I FEEL AN ATTACK ON US IS AN ATTACK ON OTHER PEACE OFFICERS, FOR EXAMPLE THE NYC SHERIFFS DEPT., CORRECTION DEPT. PAROLE OFFICERS, PROBATION OFFICERS, FEDERAL AGENTS UNDER STATE LAW HAVE PEACE OFFICER POWERS, LIKE IMMIGRATION INSPECTORS, US PARK POLICE, GSA POLICE, HOSP. POLICE ETC. NOT TOO LONG AGO STATE UNIVERSITY POLICE WERE PEACE OFFICERS, (BEFORE JAN 2000) WARRANT AND TRANSFER OFFICERS, BAY CONSTABLES SANITATION POLICE. MANY OF THE COMMENTS HERE JUST GO TO SHOW THAT POLICE STATUS DOES NOT PROVIDE THE EXPERIENCE OR EDUCATION THEY IMPLY IT DOES. THE MPTC REQUIREMENTS FOR POLICE VS PEACE OFFICER STATUS I S TWO WEEKS ADDITTIONAL TRAINING THE SIX MONTHS ACADAMY IS NOT MANDATED, IN FACT MANY POLICE OFFICERS UPSTATE GO TO WORK AND ATTEND TRAINING ON WEEKENDS , AND WE DO HAVE TO MEET THE MPTC STANDARDS,
-
Bruce W. Sokolovic
- Comments
- MTA Police are pathetic. You guys get no collars, write no summonses, and run the other way when the going gets tough. When you guys start doing some police work, maybe then you will be qualified to debate this.
-
Phase Out BTO
- Comments
- No one is attacking peace officers. It makes no sense for the MTA to maintain multiple law enforcement agencies. I think the MTA made their intentions clear when they had the MTA police start patrolling the Bridges & Tunnels. BTOs between 21 and 35 will most likely become MTA Police officers while the others will be remain in the BTO position, which will eventually die of due to attrition. Change is coming its only a matter of time, you guys knew this was coming the first day you saw MTA PD units enforcing laws on the MTAs bridges. Just like park police on Long Island and Thruway Authority officers your time is numbered. You guys will become police officers just not the way you want it.
-
Charles Klosner
- Comments
- I am NOT SIGNING IN FAVOR OF THIS PETITION! The MTAPD is a childish and unprofessional organization. When I say this, just look at the comments they wrote, ON THEIR OWN PETITION! A certain person writes about two people having anal sex. Another refers to a "dirty sanchez." How can anyone take people like this seriously? And these "police" are saying that we TBTA BTO's are nothing but toll collectors. Let me reiterate what my fellow officer's have said, and the BOLDFACE LIES told by the MTAPD- taxpayers DO NOT pay our salaries, there are no MTAPD officers at any of TBTA's 10 facilities, we have been carrying weapons for a long time and HAVE NEVER had a criminal act commited. If the MTAPD is put in charge of our facilities, THAT will be an extremely dangerous atmosphere for the public, and themselves. NOBODY knows the ins and outs of our facilities better than we do. Putting them there may cause great harm to either the public or themselves. Ask the MTAPD if they know how to evacuate a tunnel? NO!
-
BTO's
- Comments
- In Favor-438 Opposed-37, what a joke
-
BTO's Are stupid
- Comments
- This petition was setup to ridicule us. its not real yet you dumb asses keep coming back and writting stuff. It should be obvious that this a joke and meant to get under your skin. If you happy being a BTO then just let it be.
-
vincent t chiodo
-
Robert Currie TBTA OFFICER
- Comments
- THIS PETITION IS LAUGHABLE. It is shameful that one law enforcement union would try to do harm to another. It is an act of desperation, for the fact remains:TBTA OFFICERS make MORE ARRESTS and write MORE SUMMONSES than any MTA "police" officer. We've been doing it for decades and we always will!
-
Bullet
- Comments
- That's right Bob, maybe start with the unprofressionals you work with? and congrates on the arrest numbers boy I wish we had E-Z pass, and a big Thank You for NYPD for walking you through arrest. Maybe sumday tne BTO will figure it out that police work is about helping people!
-
John Johnson
- Comments
- Quote: THIS PETITION IS LAUGHABLE. It is shameful that one law enforcement union would try to do harm to another. It is an act of desperation, for the fact remains:TBTA OFFICERS make MORE ARRESTS and write MORE SUMMONSES than any MTA "police" officer. We've been doing it for decades and we always will! END Quote. Yes it is a shame that one officer would seek to do harm, but its the actions of the TBTA officers that are harming other police officers. The attacks on TBTA officers started when you starting issuing summonses to cops and video taping others. Not to mention identifying your selves as MTA police officers instead of TBTA officers. I really dont give a rats ass about you guys you dont effect me at all I dont want to spent my day sitting on bridge sometimes writing tickets the rest collecting tolls.
-
John A. Johnson
- Comments
- Further after reviewing the stats that I have access to it does appear that the TBTA issues more summonses than the MTAPD. How ever the TBTA is severely behind the MTAPD in criminal arrests. Which makes sense, the TBTA is in the perfect position to issue summonses for V&T violation since their customers are the motoring public. The MTAPD has more contact with individuals and is responsible for a much larger area. Im still waiting for further responses on FOI requests from the TBTA.
-
Tyler A. Brongo
-
BTO
- Comments
- VIDEOTAPES AND OTHER NEGATIVE ASPECTS LIKE SUMMONSES, CAME ABOUT AFTER YOUR PRESIDENTS ATTACK ON US IN AN ATTEMPT TO PREVENT A BILL FROM PASSING REGARDING STOP QUESTION AND FRISK POWERS, THIS ASSAULT WAS UNPROVOKED AND UNCALLED FOR, WE JUST HAD AN MTA POLICE OFFICER REFUSE TO SURRENDER HIS PAPERWORK TO AN OFFICER AND A SGT HAD TO RESPOND IN ORDER FOR THIS SO CALLED OFFICER TO PRODUCE HIS PAPERWORK. HIS CONTENTION WAS HE DIDN'T DO ANYTHING WRONG. NOW HOW ABOUT IF SOMEONE TAKES THAT ATTITUDE WITH YOU WHEN YOU STOP THEM, IS IT OK FOR THEM TO REFUSE TO PRODUCE THEIR LIC, AND REG BECAUSE THEY DONT FEEL THEY DID ANY THING WRONG? THIS IS STUPIDITY AND AND AN ACT OF PROVOCATION. WHAT WOULD YOU MTAPD OFFICERS DO? WHAT YOU DONT REALIZE IS THAT EVERY THING IS ON CAMERA (VIDEOTAPE) THAT OUR INTERNAL AFFAIRS HAS ACCESS TO , ITS NOT JUST ONE PERSONS WORD AGAINST ANOTHER., THESE OTHER THING YOUR PRES MENTIONS WAS THE ACTION OF ONE PERSON NOT A GROUP OF PEOPLE.
-
ELAINE MOONEY
-
wayne pirrone
-
Donald Whtmore
-
joseph t pariente
-
463
Signatures! - View Signatures
- Sign Petition