This is for all who agree that Melissa Rosenberg should not write the scripts for Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. She already ruined Twilight, by not keeping to the full effect of the book, and adding things that really didnt need to be there in exchange for leaving out more important things. Unfortunately its too late for New Moon and just have to sit back an wait for it to come out an hope that she didnt ruin that one either. But its not to late for Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. Shes already said some things about Breaking Dawn that myself and plenty of other fans do not like,

"she thinks its safe to assume the books more graphic violent scenes will be tailored to keep it accessible for Twilights teen moviegoing audience."

"Our fans are in the PG age range, and I dont feel a big necessity to see violence, and to see gore, Rosenberg said. I dont need to see that. This whole series is more about their relationship. Its not about the gore. I mean, there are some scary and special elements to it, but the series is really about relationships and coming of age and owning ones power."

So just how much is she going to cut out of the movie? From Isle Esme to First Hunt will be pretty much cut out of the movie if going by what she says. And most of the fans of the books and the movie are not just 13, but are all the way up to 50+ so how will that please the true fans if all the main parts are all cut up?

Also her saying something about how their adding visions of Edward instead of just the voices in Bella's head in New Moon, because "You cant have a Twilight without Rob Pattinson." Its not about him, its about the books and bring them to life. If I am remembering correctly in the book Bella works hard not to picture Edward, the "hallucinations" were the only thing she had left of him to remember, that didn't hurt so bad. So wouldn't adding "visions" change it?

Well anyways as I've said its to late for New Moon, but its not to late for the last 2 books. And slicing things up to make it more age appropriate doesn't seem right at all. If the movies end up being too mature for kids, then they shouldn't be allowed to watch them. And if the do, no ones to blame but their parents. I'm sure there is SO many other writers just begging to get their hands on these movies that could do SO much better then Rosenberg has. Who could really bring the books to the life the way it is supposed to, and not just worry about what the best option is to bring in more fans and money.

I'm not too good with petition writing an all that, but I hope I got my point across and that you understand. And I hope you can agree that Melissa Rosenberg should not be the script writer for Eclipse and Breaking Dawn.