Justice for American Idol

  • Author:
    n/a
  • Send To:
    All online forums dedicated to American Idol
  • Sponsored By:
  • More Info at:
Are you the Author?
This petition is not to offend anyone personally. It is strictly for opposing the idea of a fourth member of the judging panel on the reality television show American Idol, season 9.

34 Signatures

  • Britney carrington
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Anne
    • Comments
    • No 4th judge please. It has never worked on any show I've seen.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Amy
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Courtney
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Christina Stokes
    • Comments
    • This is absolutely the stupidest idea on the planet. Take it back. Now.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Christina Stokes
    • Comments
    • This is absolutely the stupidest idea on the planet. Take it back. Now.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Christina Stokes
    • Comments
    • This is absolutely the stupidest idea on the planet. Take it back. Now.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Christina Stokes
    • Comments
    • This is absolutely the stupidest idea on the planet. Take it back. Now.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • mily russi
    • Comments
    • В
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Joanna Badolato
    • Comments
    • Worst idea ever.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Alyssa
    • Comments
    • Idol jumped the shark.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Serena
    • Comments
    • OMG! No way a 4th judge sucks...this better not be a way to get rid of Paula or this show will be loosing a watcher.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Anne
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Chloe
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Amelia
    • Comments
    • DO NOT PUT A FOURTH JUDGE ON THE SHOW!!!!!!!!
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Leigh Meydrech
    • Comments
    • Idol doesn't need another judge!
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Lauren
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Lauren
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Savannah
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Beth
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Dylan
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • yae
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • kaitlyn
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • kaitlyn
    • Comments
    • worst idea ever
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Smitty
    • Comments
    • Such a stupid idea. Why change what has been working for 7 seasons. This might last until the end of this season...maybe. Totally screwing with the chemistry of Simon, Paula, Randy and Ryan.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Kristen Morrow
    • Comments
    • if you sit her in between simon and paula, i will stop watching a show i have watched religiously for 7 seasons. stupid stupid idea.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Natalie
    • Comments
    • They cannot add another judge thats freaking stupid. She better not sit in between saula or i'll go freaking insane!
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Sharon
    • Comments
    • Why? Hate the idea of a 4th judge.love u paula!
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Lara Aranjuez
    • Comments
    • i don't like the idea of having a fourth judge. it's stupid.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Isabel
    • Comments
    • В
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • vinc
    • Comments
    • I think a fourth judge won't change the ratings, just look back at seasons before. they're better.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • vinc
    • Comments
    • I think a fourth judge won't change the ratings, just look back at seasons before. they're better.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Margaret Clayton
    • Comments
    • I feel that a fourth judge will do nothing but ruin the already just fine chemistry between Simon Paula and Randy, and it just might be the ruination of the show.
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No
  • Elizabeth MacDonald
    • Comments
    • This will just destroy AI
    • Do you think a fourth judge will be good for ratings?
    • No
    • Would it be good if this forth judge were to sit in between Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul?
    • No
    • Do you think a fourth judge will affect the chemistry between Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, Randy jackson and Ryan Seacrest?
    • No