Academic Freedom in Britain
-
Author:
n/a -
Send To:
Professor John Garside, Vice-Chancellor, University of Manchester Institute of Science & Technology (UK)
-
Sponsored By:
International academic community -
More Info at:
We the undersigned members of the international academic community call upon the University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology to abandon its inquiry into Professor Mona Bakers decision to sever links between her journals and Israeli universities.
Mona Bakers decision was taken in pursuance of an academic boycott of Israel. The claim that this infringed the academic freedom of the two Israeli academics she removed from the boards of her journals is entirely spurious: they remain as free as ever to say what they wish, and are, unlike Mona Baker, in no danger of dismissal. The claim that her decision was racially motivated is also entirely spurious and unwarranted: it depends on dishonestly equating criticism of the Israeli government with anti-Semitism.
The inquiry UMIST is conducting is a disciplinary procedure in all but name, except that Professor Baker has none of the protections of a defendant, such as the right to examine witnesses against her, to see their evidence, or even to know their identity. The Sunday Telegraph (UK) of November 17 quotes a UMIST official as saying that it will be decided by Christmas whether she will be dismissed, and UMISTs website carries an official statement condemning her in advance.
We regard this inquiry as a grave assault on academic freedom and the right to legitimate political activity and call upon UMIST to abandon it before the reputation of the university is further damaged.
Mona Bakers decision was taken in pursuance of an academic boycott of Israel. The claim that this infringed the academic freedom of the two Israeli academics she removed from the boards of her journals is entirely spurious: they remain as free as ever to say what they wish, and are, unlike Mona Baker, in no danger of dismissal. The claim that her decision was racially motivated is also entirely spurious and unwarranted: it depends on dishonestly equating criticism of the Israeli government with anti-Semitism.
The inquiry UMIST is conducting is a disciplinary procedure in all but name, except that Professor Baker has none of the protections of a defendant, such as the right to examine witnesses against her, to see their evidence, or even to know their identity. The Sunday Telegraph (UK) of November 17 quotes a UMIST official as saying that it will be decided by Christmas whether she will be dismissed, and UMISTs website carries an official statement condemning her in advance.
We regard this inquiry as a grave assault on academic freedom and the right to legitimate political activity and call upon UMIST to abandon it before the reputation of the university is further damaged.
1059 Signatures
-
Terry
- Country
- USA
-
Majid A
- Country
- UK
- Institution (for identification only)
- BPP Law School
-
Michael C
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Philosophy
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Wales Swansea
-
Colwyn W
- Country
- Wales
- Discipline
- Philosophy
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Wales
-
howard m
- Title
- Mr
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Discipline
- Italian
- Institution (for identification only)
- University Wales of Swansea
-
Zaneb A
- Title
- miss
- Country
- uk
- Institution (for identification only)
- UMIST
-
keith h
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- Wales
- Discipline
- Geography
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Wales Swansea
-
Tayyab R
- Title
- Software Consultant
- Country
- UK
-
Eithne O
- Title
- Dr.
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Translation Studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University
-
Aiden C
- Title
- Mr.
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Psychology
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University
-
John S
- Title
- Emeritus Professor
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- English Language
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Birmingham
-
Emmet M
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Marketing
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University
-
Anne M
- Title
- Ms
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Philosophy
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Wales Swansea
-
Rumy H
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- UK
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Leeds
-
Simon G
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Discipline
- School of Education
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Leicester
-
Rami A
- Country
- England
- Institution (for identification only)
- UMIST
-
john h
- Title
- mr
- Country
- uk
- Discipline
- history
-
Gabriela S
- Country
- Uruguay
- Discipline
- Translation Studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University
-
David S
- Title
- Professor of Political Geography
- Country
- England
- Discipline
- Geography
-
adel_g_nasser
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- England
- Discipline
- IT
- Institution (for identification only)
- UMIST
-
Maggie G
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Textual studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University
-
Saturnino L
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Computer Science
- Institution (for identification only)
- Trinity College Dublin
-
Sonia C
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Discipline
- Italian and Translation Studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Portsmouth
-
moses
- Country
- uk
-
Dan J
- Title
- Mr
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Biotechnology
- Institution (for identification only)
- DCU
-
Theodora L
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Biology
- Institution (for identification only)
- NUIM
-
James B
- Title
- Professor
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Computer Science
- Institution (for identification only)
- UCC, Cork
-
Rachel G
- Title
- Prof.
- Country
- Israel
- Institution (for identification only)
- Tel Aviv University
-
Andrew C
- Title
- Professor
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Psychology
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Leicester
-
Myriam S
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Translation Studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Salford
-
Dorothy N
- Title
- PhD
- Country
- Israel
- Discipline
- Retired
-
Shehla K
- Title
- Ms.
- Country
- United Kingdom
- Discipline
- Government
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Manchester
-
Trevor S
- Title
- Prof.
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Chemistry
- Institution (for identification only)
- University College, Cork
-
Margot S
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- French
- Institution (for identification only)
- UCC
-
claire h
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- England
- Discipline
- Psychology
- Institution (for identification only)
- Bolton Institute
-
Nick H
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Medicine
- Institution (for identification only)
- Imperial College
-
John-Kevin B
- Title
- Lecturer
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Industrial Relations
- Institution (for identification only)
- Dublin City University Business School
-
Paidi C
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Computer Science
- Institution (for identification only)
- UCC
-
Alex F
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Computer Science
- Institution (for identification only)
- University College Cork
-
Dj. K
- Title
- Professor
- Country
- USA
- Discipline
- Comparative Literature
- Institution (for identification only)
- Pennsylvania State University
-
Dr. Ibrahim M
- Title
- Lecturer
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Translation Studies
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Edinburgh
-
Darren M
- Title
- Dr
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Bioinfomatics
- Institution (for identification only)
- UCC
-
Neil R
- Title
- Mr
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Historian
- Institution (for identification only)
- City and Islington College
-
Irene B
- Title
- Professor
- Country
- UK
-
Richard H
- Title
- Professor
- Country
- UK
- Discipline
- Linguistics
- Institution (for identification only)
- UCL
-
Henry D
- Country
- Britain
-
Paul S
- Title
- Mr.
- Country
- Ireland
- Discipline
- Computer Science
- Institution (for identification only)
- University College Cork, Ireland
-
Dr. Jean D
- Title
- Chair, School of Translation and Interpretation
- Country
- Canada
- Discipline
- Translation
- Institution (for identification only)
- University of Ottawa
-
MYKA
- Country
- Leicester, UK
-
Dimitris A
- Title
- Mr
- Country
- Greece
- Discipline
- Translation
- Institution (for identification only)
- UMIST
-
1059
Signatures! - View Signatures
- Sign Petition