End Over-Censorship on Yahoo! Answers
-
Author:
n/a -
Send To:
Yahoo.com Yahoo Answers
-
Sponsored By:
-
More Info at:
This is the online petition to encourage Yahoo! Answers to better its censorship practices of questioners' and answerers' posts. Signing this petition is a call to Yahoo for less restrictive community guidelines and less arbitrary, unilateral omissions of user content.
Case example:
** I have held an email account with Yahoo for years. I began using Yahoo Answers a few months ago. I answer a lot more questions than I ask. The first question I had censored (deleted) was about an entertainer whose name I could not recall. He told racial jokes. After a few days, the question was deleted; no one attempted to answer before the deletion. I believe I appealed this action.
Moreover, there is no shortage of ethnically, racially offensive questions and answers on Yahoo. I do not follow the endurance of these questions, but the responses and frequency are to be noted.
** The second question that Yahoo censored was concerning female on male oral sex. This one was starred twenty-four times and received about 33 answers. The violation type was "adult". At the same time this question was deleted, there rings in scores of adult sexual questions and remarks that are equally sexually explicit if not more so.
** Then another question was for the purpose of getting someone to vote on an earlier question so it may be resolved. I made the mistake of not describing which answerers needed the tiebreaker. So, I allowed the answerers to inadvertently vote and turn a two-way tie into a three-way tie. This is considered to be soliciting and I should have just sent a message to my contacts. Nevertheless, while that post was justifiably removed, one of the two questions I posted and linked into the deleted solicitation post was also deleted. So, Yahoo conducted a 2-for-1 censorship.
I have had another question deleted because it was posted twice. This was not intentional, however. Either due to a browser error or the Answers web page itself. Here is the link to the Yahoo! Answers Community Guidelines:
http://answers.yahoo.com/info/community_guidelines
I am not the only person who has noticed this trend of blatant over-censorship and so-called "political correctness" from Yahoo. I ask that you join me by signing this petition so that Yahoo, a respected and world-renown web host and site, will test one or more of the following actions:
1) Keep the site as it is except allow users to place a minimum age requirement; safe search filter; and/or a succinct Captcha-style aptitude test germane to the question before questions can be reported or answered. This will enhance safety by ensuring that minors are protected from adult content and spam bots, p.c. trolls, and point trolls are not misusing the questioners. Succinct aptitude test will reduce answers (unless they are credited more points for the hassle) but will lead to more serious answers.
2) Keep the current site as it is, but beta a spin-off version of Yahoo! Answers. The spin-off should be less censored and allow for intellectual, adult content. Make the reporting violations procedure less arbitrary and allow real-time appeals (like chat or I.M. if available). This will allow for better answers to harder questions. Adult or sexual queries will get more honest, more uncensored responses.
3) Keep the site as it is except, when a question is reported then deleted, allow the questioner's contact(s) to view the question in private (if they are of age) and vote on it. Do not simply delete an entire question that might have gotten positive feedback from a user's contacts anyway. Some groups of contacts on Yahoo Answers are solely connected to discuss mature or politically incorrect questions. I doubt if a user will lose many contacts' respect for posting an offensive question.
These are my suggestions to Yahoo! Answers. There is strength in numbers. I urge you to sign this petition against excessive online censorship.
Case example:
** I have held an email account with Yahoo for years. I began using Yahoo Answers a few months ago. I answer a lot more questions than I ask. The first question I had censored (deleted) was about an entertainer whose name I could not recall. He told racial jokes. After a few days, the question was deleted; no one attempted to answer before the deletion. I believe I appealed this action.
Moreover, there is no shortage of ethnically, racially offensive questions and answers on Yahoo. I do not follow the endurance of these questions, but the responses and frequency are to be noted.
** The second question that Yahoo censored was concerning female on male oral sex. This one was starred twenty-four times and received about 33 answers. The violation type was "adult". At the same time this question was deleted, there rings in scores of adult sexual questions and remarks that are equally sexually explicit if not more so.
** Then another question was for the purpose of getting someone to vote on an earlier question so it may be resolved. I made the mistake of not describing which answerers needed the tiebreaker. So, I allowed the answerers to inadvertently vote and turn a two-way tie into a three-way tie. This is considered to be soliciting and I should have just sent a message to my contacts. Nevertheless, while that post was justifiably removed, one of the two questions I posted and linked into the deleted solicitation post was also deleted. So, Yahoo conducted a 2-for-1 censorship.
I have had another question deleted because it was posted twice. This was not intentional, however. Either due to a browser error or the Answers web page itself. Here is the link to the Yahoo! Answers Community Guidelines:
http://answers.yahoo.com/info/community_guidelines
I am not the only person who has noticed this trend of blatant over-censorship and so-called "political correctness" from Yahoo. I ask that you join me by signing this petition so that Yahoo, a respected and world-renown web host and site, will test one or more of the following actions:
1) Keep the site as it is except allow users to place a minimum age requirement; safe search filter; and/or a succinct Captcha-style aptitude test germane to the question before questions can be reported or answered. This will enhance safety by ensuring that minors are protected from adult content and spam bots, p.c. trolls, and point trolls are not misusing the questioners. Succinct aptitude test will reduce answers (unless they are credited more points for the hassle) but will lead to more serious answers.
2) Keep the current site as it is, but beta a spin-off version of Yahoo! Answers. The spin-off should be less censored and allow for intellectual, adult content. Make the reporting violations procedure less arbitrary and allow real-time appeals (like chat or I.M. if available). This will allow for better answers to harder questions. Adult or sexual queries will get more honest, more uncensored responses.
3) Keep the site as it is except, when a question is reported then deleted, allow the questioner's contact(s) to view the question in private (if they are of age) and vote on it. Do not simply delete an entire question that might have gotten positive feedback from a user's contacts anyway. Some groups of contacts on Yahoo Answers are solely connected to discuss mature or politically incorrect questions. I doubt if a user will lose many contacts' respect for posting an offensive question.
These are my suggestions to Yahoo! Answers. There is strength in numbers. I urge you to sign this petition against excessive online censorship.
28 Signatures
-
J. Larkin
- Comments
- Viva La Opinion
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
Daniella Thompson
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
Michael Muirhead
- Comments
- I've been suspended many times myself for nothing more than telling the simple, unvarnished clinical truth about women's sexual, reproductive and genital health matters.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
ovais
- Comments
- can u tell me how can i recover my frinds and family contacts which has deleted by my son and also he deleted my address books
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
Mike Rayhill
- Comments
- It has gotten ridiculous.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- no.
-
alex demarco
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Matthew Beck
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
vince
- Comments
- HEll YEAH! I have a petition that deals with yahoo's unfair policy, sign it? http://www.petitionspot.com/petitions/yahooanswers
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Bryan White
- Comments
- I believe in freedom of speech, even in the private sector. We're all adults here. Make an adult-oriented version of Y!A for unhindered discussion. Let fools declare themselves fools freely, let the controversial be controversial, and the wise be wise, and let the user judge for himself what to disregard, rather than censor it.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
H MORIN
- Comments
- YAHOO ANSWERS SUCKS
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- YES
-
J S
- Comments
- I totally agree, many other websites have ridiculous censorship too
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- No, I used to.
-
Chris H.
- Comments
- Reporting has been abused for quite a while now, but it is getting worse
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes, but suspended
-
Wesley
- Comments
- Stop needless censorship people on yahoo are too sensitive.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Peter Aaron McLean
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Gerry Oz
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
Carmen Ramos
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Paul Baudler
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
Karissa Nelson
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- no
-
Fasil Alemante
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- No
-
Ben
- Comments
- Yahoo have an agenda they hold VERY close to their chest. The number of anti-religious Q's and A's which are reported and censored is revolting.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Kevin clark
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- No
-
Chris Kozz
- Comments
- Don't be Leftist pricks, YA
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Icarus Chan
- Comments
- DEFINITELY I don't understand why INTEGRATION or TANGENTS problems can VIOLATE THE COMMUNITY GUIDELINES it spoil the effort of the one who SPENT TIME ANSWERING IT
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Kmdr
- Comments
- This is an important petiton. Yahoo is abusive, arbitrary and unfair in the practice of removing answers and questions.
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Adrian Carroll
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Alex Davidson
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Jordan danger plaisted
- Comments
- I have had important real questions deleted because I'm a "troll"
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- Yes
-
Luis T Puig
- Comments
- Yahoo...Hypocrisy at its finest! They say they are "open to all ideas"... but in reality they are ONLY opened to liberal ideas...reminds me of my days living under the USSR... Truth is Truth, and politics will never be Truth, politics is just that politics. Beware people when even scientific findings like the ones in my book What Nature Intended, Six factors Demonstrating Homosexuality to be a Dysfunction, and in which solutions and help is offered to people suffering from the homosexual affliction are blocked, that is the sign of a close minded society, one that WILL pay the price for it and on second thought, Yahoo censoring things is not hypocrisy, it is stupidity!
- Yes or No, Do you have an account on Yahoo Answers?
- yes
-
28
Signatures! - View Signatures
- Sign Petition